The Return of Malthus : Why We Need To Be Very Very Scared



For those of you who are hearing of this gentleman for the first time, he was the medieval economist who postulated (the Malthusian Theory) that nature will keep producing population growth, until it creates a resource crunch, which will then create a series of natural calamities, decimating the population and setting off the cycle again.

Declaimer: This article written was originally in April 2010 and some of the data points may be outdated.

Intuitively, he found a lot of adherents, because, in the old, pre-industrial, deflationary economy, this was true; till man learned ‘systematic innovation’ and started to create new professions and Economics became a tool in his hands to achieve progress.

After 1850, the world learned about inflation, Monetary Policy,

After 1850, the world learned about inflation, Monetary Policy, and the Industrial Revolution, which created the modern era. Thereafter, the ‘natural limits’ to any constraint started to shift outwards, until 150 years later, we started to believe that even a desperately poor country like India has a hope of beating the Malthusian Theory.     

After Japan, it became the done thing to argue that human ingenuity would be able to beat all known (resource) constraints. You could have a tiny island nation with almost no natural resources, and the dubious distinction of having a quarter of all known natural disasters, which could grow to be the most productive nation in the world, by all known measures of savings and wealth accumulation.

As always, we Indians learn the wrong lessons. We extrapolated this to tell ourselves that our huge population would never hit a resource crunch and that our ingenuity would always delay the onset of Armageddon.

We forgot Father Time. Every time Man beat the Malthusian Clock, he had a lot of time to see the threat and react to it. Sometimes, serendipity helped. The “Green Revolution” saved India from the hunger and famine that it had started to see in the 1960s. Remember PL-480?

This time, Global Warming will set off a series of events that might not give us enough time to react. If the current El Nino effect turns out to be a regular affair, how many years of 60% monsoon deficits can we survive, before we are reduced to the basket case that we were in the 1960s?

The current monsoon deficit may well turn out to be the most comprehensive, countrywide drought that we have seen in the last 100 years. We have been following coal-based energy usage, refusing to give up our right to pollute, with the “dog in the manger” attitude that it was the West that had done the most damage till now. But the worst affected will be us; the frail, weak uptick that we have seen these last 10 years, will be overshadowed by what follows.

If we have 3 monsoon failures in a row, do we have the Desalination Industry that will produce enough clean, potable water to quench an entire nation’s thirst? How quickly do we have communication systems to create a culture of Rain Harvesting, Water Conservation/ Recycling, wastewater treatment, etc? No doubt, Israel has beaten all limitations to agricultural productivity, but how quickly can we duplicate those achievements?

In the short run, we will need to quickly create a market for Water

In the short run, we will need to quickly create a market for Water. There is no way you can tell a population that something has suddenly become precious, without putting a price on it.

 The reason this will not happen is this: Mamata Banerjee/ The Left/ The BJP will politicize the issue till any progress is stalemated. Just as any concessions given to the Kyoto negotiations are seen as a sign of weakness, and just as we stuck to our mispricing of petroleum products despite running ourselves bankrupt, I am very sure that no national consensus on water will be built, until it is too late.

This time, the consequence will not be economic, but humanitarian. Geopolitical think tanks have postulated that India will be one of the worst-affected victims of Global Warming, with an estimated 100 mn people dying as a direct consequence of its effects.

If 2009 is to water, what 1991 was to Forex, then we have the same man in charge. The PM hopefully has the same understanding of this problem that he had of the Forex crunch. Certainly, he has the mandate to move swiftly on this issue. He just needs to tick off the following policy prescription:

. He just needs to tick off the following policy prescription:
  • Get off your high horse on Kyoto We are looking stupid, defending our right to pollute just because the West has done what it did.
  • The country that gets off the ground first, on Alternate Energy, will see a clear technological leadership in one of the most important pillars of economic progress in the current century: Clean Energy. The Solar Mission, if it is serious, is a step in the right direction. It needs to be followed up with the development of a quasi-fiscal investment market that subsidizes the excess capital cost of Solar Energy, leaving enough space for cost-led innovation.
  • Then focus on the Clean Energy applications. The first would be a full commodity market in Water: just make Water enormously profitable to everyone and his uncle to get into it, if only for the tax shelters available.
  • Create a panel of IDFC-like nodal investment institutions, whose bonds have a 200% weighted tax-free deduction, i.e. for every Rs.100 subscribed to the bonds, you get Rs.200 as a deduction (with an investment cap of Rs.5 lacs per year, far better than raising the taxable limit). That provides a 70% subsidy to the Capital Cost of Solar power, which the Institution channelizes as debt to the sector. Set high debt norms with long paybacks for eligible projects.
  • Now let a thousand flowers bloom. Include the Desalination Industry in this panel of Clean Energy users. Create a pseudo-market in “water paper”, where credits are given to those who recycle Industrial (Waste) Water, converting it to agricultural-grade Clean Water. This should create millions of recycling units, mostly based on solar applications, a variant of the Solar Water Heating Systems that have been so successful in rural areas.
  • Promote the same ‘water paper’ to create a micro-irrigation industry, through which farmers can buy entitlement to water through the adoption of micro-irrigation techniques. Target subsidies through a small set of producers, where the leakages would be less.

The first step is to create a sense of crisis BEFORE a real one is created (I hope I have not spoken too late). The current monsoon may be typical of many more to come, and we will need a typical Dhirubhai Ambani overkill: create a giant capacity, 100 times the water needs of Delhi, then get to work at making it dependent on Clean Energy, maybe Solar.

The problem with a product market for water is that the (commodity) prices will be very volatile, with prices collapsing during a good monsoon. So it has to be an investment-led market, not a product-market, i.e. the Capital cost would have to be contributed through a market instrument, similar to the Timeshare industry, or the One-Time Premium Insurance products. If all sides of the industry are left open to market pricing, then there would be enough space for innovation to create a spectacular winner. A co that either reduces the cost of the project, which can reduce the cost of capital, or which can extract other operating efficiencies, will find itself at the top of a very large industry.

“The cost of communication will go to zero”, said Dhirubhai Ambani to a recruit in 1989, when asked about the Next Big Thing for the ‘90s. For the new Millenium, Reliance should have been working at taking the cost of energy to zero. Certainly, if it can take the cost of Water to zero, it would have made every Indian its customer: another Dhirubhai dream.

There is more greatness for anyone interested. A co that sits at the heart of all Indian energy usage is bound to be the next Reliance (if it isn’t Reliance itself). 80% of the energy used in India’s villages, goes into water management. Think of the economic potential that will get unlocked by someone who takes that out



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

On Key

Related Posts

Scroll to Top

As a participant in the Dr Mentoring Program (DMP) four years ago, I can say with confidence that the program has been instrumental in shaping my approach towards managing operating cash flow and developing strategies for becoming a successful doctor entrepreneur.

Under the guidance of Mr. Sanjeev Pandiya, a seasoned ex-CFO of many listed companies like SRF, Jindal Steel, and Haulonix, the program provided us with invaluable insights into the financial aspects of running a medical practice. From understanding the basics of accounting and financial statements to learning about cash flow management, the program covered all the essential concepts required to successfully run a medical practice.

Moreover, Mr. Pandiya’s expertise and guidance helped us develop a strategic mindset to approach our profession as entrepreneurs. We were taught how to think outside the box and innovate to create unique offerings and build a brand that sets us apart from the competition.

Overall, I can confidently say that the DMP has had a profound impact on my professional growth as a doctor entrepreneur. The program’s emphasis on financial management and strategic thinking has equipped me with the tools to build a successful and sustainable medical practice. I would highly recommend this program to any doctor looking to enhance their entrepreneurial skills and take their practice to the next level.


Dr Yatin Shinde

Career Guru

Registration Form

Join Weekly Webinar

Please fill this form to get the invitation for my weekly webinars that I conduct for our community. In these sessions I talked about wide range of subjects like investing, personal finance and answer the questions you might have. 

Join The Community

Please fill this form below to join this community of like minded individuals with a common objective ,to build a 3-dimentional understanding of the investing world.